G+ is a community for professionals, academics and entrepreneurs to connect through online discussions and in-person meetings. You will continue to see G+ Insights (formerly GLG News) here as well as on the G+ website, where you can share and discuss the G+ Insights you read.
July 26, 2011
Megadeal Unites Drug Rivals | online.wsj.com
I give the Express Scripts / Medco Health Solutions deal a 60% chance of being approved by the Federal Trade Commission. I think it’s going to be a very tough fight for antitrust approval, but perhaps not for the reasons you think. The Agreement and Plan of Merger filed on Friday gives us a peek at the companies’ strategy for clearing the antitrust hurdles. But note that there is no termination fee if the companies don’t get antitrust clearance.
ESRX-MHS: Strategic and Market Analysis
July 25, 2011
The Express Scripts / Medco Health Solutions deal makes sense given the dynamics of the PBM industry. At the same time, a successful transaction would signal the end of the PBM industry's major growth opportunities and the transition to a more mature, highly consolidated market. The post-2015 world looks much less rosy for PBMs as the generic wave crests and the government crowds out private payers.
What's Behind Teva's Cephalon Deal
May 3, 2011
Teva to Buy Cephalon in $6.8b Transaction | www.bloomberg.com
This is a great, albeit expensive, strategic move by Teva. Management clearly recognizes the business model problem looming ahead for the generic drug business. The deal boosts Teva's brand business while maintaining a broadly diversified revenue base, positioning Teva as the "anti-Pfizer."The pharma industry of tomorrow will be about expensive drugs for small patient populations and cheap drugs for large populations. I wonder how many manufacturers will be ready.
2011 Part D Market Share: A Win for Humana and Walmart
April 29, 2011
Next Monday, Humana will report results for the first quarter of 2011. Based on my independent analysis of CMS data on Medicare Part D Prescription Drug Plans (PDPs), the company will have a lot to brag about next week for its Retail segment: Humana had a net gain of about 570,000 PDP enrollees, more than any other organization in 2011. The Humana Walmart-Preferred Rx Plan, a preferred pharmacy network PDP launched in October 2010, is now the fifth-largest PDP in the U.S.
Express Scripts' Disruptive Specialty Strategy
April 14, 2011
Express Scripts is ahead of its PBM peers with an innovative and risky strategy for absorbing the buy-and-bill specialty drug spending from health care providers. If successful, the company will become the clear leader in a big new addressable market for PBM services. It also puts them on a collision course with AmerisourceBergen and McKesson for control over specialty channels to physician offices and clinics.
Thoughts on the Catalyst-Walgreen Deal
March 10, 2011
Walgreen to Sell Unit for $525 Million | online.wsj.com
This is a big move for Catalyst, which vaults ahead of its competitors to become the fifth largest PBM behind the Big 3 PBMs—CVS Caremark , Express Scripts , and Medco Health Solutions —and United Health’s Prescription Solutions. Even so, Catalyst will have less than 5% of the total U.S. prescription volume vs. about 70% for the top four. Below I discuss the implications for: Walgreens The PBM industry CVS Caremark
Medtronic Dumps Novation: Why GPOs Should Worry
March 1, 2011
Medtronic Makes Bold Pact-Ending Move Amid Medical-Device Woes | online.wsj.com
Medtronic is questioning the core of a GPO’s business model—pooling member purchase volumes in exchange for lower prices from manufacturers and wholesalers. Medtronic is the first company to make such a bold public move against GPOs, but other manufacturers are rethinking their channel and contracting strategies. Direct contracting is an existential mega-threat facing the GPO industry. A weaker GPO industry would likely be a net positive for wholesalers, particularly Cardinal Health .
CVS Caremark: Still Searching for Synergy
February 8, 2011
In the latest results from CVS Caremark , the company was not even able to meet the lowered expectations for its PBM business that the company had set for itself just three months ago. Unless there is major progress, I still predict a 2012 Caremark spin off for the reasons outlined in When will CVS and Caremark split up? Comments by new CEO Larry Merlo suggest that this scenario is now under active consideration.
Walgreens Joins the Attack on PBM Mail Profits
January 18, 2011
Walgreen aims to fill more 90-day prescriptions | www.chicagobusiness.com
Low-price retail fulfillment of 90-day prescriptions is a threat to PBM profits. Walgreens joins Walmart and CVS Caremark in pursuing strategies that eliminate the traditional out-of-pocket cost difference for consumers between mail and retail pharmacies. Will plan sponsors pay attention and create a strategic vulnerability in the profit model of Express Scripts and Medco Health Solutions ?
Cardinal Gets to China First with Zuellig Pharma Acquisition
November 29, 2010
Cardinal Health Acquires Leading Pharmaceutical Distributor in China | ir.cardinalhealth.com
The era of global wholesale is dawning. The acquisition represents the first major distribution investment outside of North America by one of the Big Three U.S. wholesalers. I've long pointed to China as a logical growth platform for U.S. wholesalers as in my January 2007 post 3 Ways for Drug Wholesalers to Grow.
November 1, 2010
McKesson to Purchase US Oncology in a Transaction Valued at $2.16 Billion | phx.corporate-ir.net
This deal is a big win for McKesson, which now solidifies its position as the #2 specialty products distributor. McKesson also picks up the services and Group Purchasing Organization (GPOs) businesses of US Oncology. On the other hand, Cardinal Health now has an even bigger challenge in rebuilding its specialty business and diversify away from its two mega-customers, CVS Caremark and Walgreen . See Double Trouble for Cardinal Health. Time to go shopping?
Double Trouble for Cardinal Health
October 14, 2010
Cardinal's recently released annual 10-K filing for the fiscal year ending June 30, 2010show a company that's increasingly at the mercy of its two dominant customers. CVS Caremark’s retail pharmacy business and Walgreens are now half of Cardinal’s drug distribution business. Even more troubling, it looks like Cardinal lost substantial market share when we exclude its two mega-customers and account for inflation.
CVS Caremark: More Happy Talk, But Hard Work Remains
October 12, 2010
CVS Caremark Says Drug-Benefit Business Strong. | online.wsj.com
CVS Caremark held its 2010 Analyst Day last Friday. Management told a good story, but the underlying message remains the same: Keep waiting because the pot of gold is (still) just around the corner. Many of the programs described at the meeting sound quite intriguing in theory but are not likely to translate into an insurmountable competitive advantage. Thus, I still expect CVS to spin off Caremark, but probably not until 2012.
Walmart-Humana: An Inevitable Surprise for Pharmacies and PBMs
October 4, 2010
Humana, Wal-Mart Launch Cheaper Medicare Drug Plan | online.wsj.com
Walmart is once again challenging the conventional wisdom about profitability and market share with a lower cost, consumer-driven plan design. Once you understand this “incentivized preferred network design” (my words), then you’ll grasp its disruptive potential for retail and mail-order pharmacies.The announcement is also an “Inevitable Surprise”—the predictable outgrowth of Walmart’s observable actions and statements about the pharmacy and PBM industries.
Health Care Reform: Impact on Drug Channels
March 25, 2010
The Doctors of the House | online.wsj.com
Pharmacy Benefit Managers (PBMs) will gain from the expanded coverage in the bill. The “transparency” requirements, while an unnecessary reporting burden, should not be material. Retail pharmacies will benefit from increased prescription volume and various legislative “fixes,” but face margin risk as the uninsured get the advantage of third-party bargaining power. Drug wholesalers will primarily benefit along with their pharmaceutical manufacturer suppliers.
Walgreen’s PBM Bypass Strategy
March 11, 2010
Walgreen, Delta In Talks Over Prescription Drug Plan | online.wsj.com
A WAG-DAL arrangement signals a possible longer-term disintermediation threat to the Pharmacy Benefit Manager (PBM) business model in the large employer market. Walgreens has built the deepest, broadest multi-channel platform for pharmaceutical distribution and has an especially strong position for specialty drugs. An employer doesn’t need an intermediary (PBM) to assemble and manage a network that only has a single pharmacy provider.
Maintenance Choice Update: CVS Gain, Caremark Same
February 11, 2010
CVS Posts 10% Rise in Net | online.wsj.com
CVS Caremark's Maintenance Choice program is growing rapidly as a benefit design option, demonstrating that payers are willing to accept more restricted pharmacy networks in exchange for savings and control. The outcome for the pharmacy industry will be more rapid consolidation. At the same time, I still wonder if Maintenance Choice provides enough competitive differentiation to help Caremark win new Pharmacy Benefit Manager (PBM) business.
No Visible Revenue Synergies in CVS Caremark's Latest Numbers
February 23, 2009
CVS Net Rises; Finance Chief Plans to Retire | online.wsj.com
CVS Caremark’s PBM businesses are not becoming a larger share of prescriptions filled at CVS retail pharmacies. Put another way, the flagship Maintenance Choice program may be appealing to payers and consumers, but there is not yet a quantitatively visible shift in CVS' retail activity. If CVS pharmacies are taking retail pharmacy market share, then it’s not yet as a result of corporate co-ownership with a PBM.
January 16, 2009
Health-Care Outlays Climb at Slowest Rate in Years | online.wsj.com
U.S. spending on outpatient prescription drugs grew by only 4.9 percent in 2007, which was below overall health care spending growth of 6.1 percent. Public funds (primarily Medicare and Medicaid) paid for 36 percent of total retail prescription drug spending in 2007. So, how much money do pharmacies make from Medicare and Medicaid? The answers may surprise you. Here’s what I found: (1) Medicaid remains the most profitable third-party payer for independent pharmacies. (2) Despite what you may have heard, gross margins on third-party insurance business are growing at independent pharmacies. (3) The generic price war that was triggered by Wal-Mart is squeezing pharmacy margins on cash-pay consumers. While $4 generics may be good news for uninsured/underinsured patients, they are bad news for pharmacy owners.
An Unfortunate Victory for EU Repackagers
December 9, 2008
EU Exec Drops Drug Repackaging Ban Plan | www.reuters.com
Reuters reported on Friday that the EU plans to drop a proposed ban on repackaging of pharmaceuticals. In my opinion, dropping the ban is a very bad decision. Repackaging eliminates the benefit of just about every practical anti-counterfeit tracking technology, including the emerging serialization requirements in some EU countries. Apparently, tablets can even beremoved from blister packs under EU law. It’s hard to see how this will benefit consumers.
February 7, 2012
What do the cloud, collaboration and virtualization have in common?
January 27, 2012
Clinical diagnostic acquisitions dominate 2011 top ten list
January 12, 2012
Gene therapy success threatens drugs for hemophilia and rare diseases
December 13, 2011
Medtech M&A activity accelerates in 2011
November 30, 2011